Blog

Subscription churn rate: how to calculate it and what's normal

Churn rate is the one number that tells you whether a subscription business is growing or just busy. You can add fifty subscribers a month and still shrink if you lose sixty. It's also easy to calculate wrongly, easy to compare against the wrong benchmark, and easy to misread. This guide covers how to work it out, what's normal for products like coffee, supplements and pet food, and how to tell which part of it to fix first.

What subscription churn rate is

Your churn rate is the share of subscribers you had at the start of a period who stopped subscribing during it. For most stores the period is a month, so it's usually quoted as monthly churn: "we lose 5% of our subscribers a month".

A subscriber counts as churned when their subscription actually ends. That happens in two very different ways:

  • Voluntary churn. The customer chose to leave: they cancelled from their account, or asked you to cancel for them.
  • Involuntary churn. The customer didn't choose anything. Their card was declined, the retries ran out, and the subscription stopped. Many of these customers didn't even know.

Keep these apart from the start. They have different causes and different fixes, and one total number hides which one is hurting you.

How to calculate churn rate

The formula is simple:

Monthly churn rate = subscribers lost during the month ÷ active subscribers at the start of the month × 100

Say you start October with 400 active subscriptions. During the month, 21 customers cancel and 3 subscriptions stop after their payment retries run out. You also gain 30 new subscribers.

  • Churn rate: 24 ÷ 400 = 6%
  • Voluntary churn: 21 ÷ 400 = 5.25%
  • Involuntary churn: 3 ÷ 400 = 0.75%

The 30 new subscribers aren't in the calculation. That's the most common mistake: dividing by the subscribers you have at the end of the month, or by an average, lets a good month of sign-ups make your churn look lower than it is. Growth and churn are separate numbers, so keep them that way.

The cases that trip people up

  • Subscribers who start and cancel in the same month. They weren't in your starting count, so leave them out of the lost count too. But track them separately. A customer who cancels before their first renewal is usually telling you something about the product page, the price or the frequency, not about the product.
  • Paused subscriptions. A pause isn't churn: the customer still has a subscription, and you didn't lose them. Leave paused subscriptions out of both counts, and watch how many resume. A pause that never ends is a slow cancellation.
  • Failed payments. Count a subscription as churned when the retries run out and billing stops, not at the first decline. A card that fails on Monday and is updated on Thursday wasn't lost.
  • Cancelling at the end of the paid cycle. If a cancellation takes effect at the end of the period the customer has paid for, count it in the month it ends. Some customers change their mind before then.
  • Prepaid plans. A customer who paid for six deliveries up front can't really churn until the sixth. Calculate their churn separately, or they'll make your monthly figure look better than the pay-as-you-go side really is.
  • Small numbers. With 50 subscribers, two cancellations is 4% and four is 8%. That's noise, not a trend. Until you have a few hundred subscribers, look at three-month totals rather than any single month.

What's a good churn rate for subscriptions?

Benchmarks are a rough guide. Every source defines churn a little differently, and your products, price and frequencies matter more than your industry. With that said, here's a sense of the ranges:

  • Recurly's benchmarks for July 2026 put the median monthly churn rate for ecommerce subscriptions at 4.25%: 2.87% voluntary and 1.38% involuntary.
  • Category estimates for replenishment products like household consumables and supplements commonly fall around 5–8% a month, with coffee and pet food a little wider.
  • Curated boxes and meal kits run higher, often 8–15% a month, because customers are buying novelty rather than something they run out of.

Monthly percentages look small, so it helps to see what they add up to over a year. If you stopped adding subscribers today, this is roughly how many of your current ones you'd still have in twelve months:

Monthly churnStill subscribed after a yearAverage subscriber lifetime
2%78%50 months
4%61%25 months
6%48%about 17 months
8%37%about 12 months

The average lifetime is one divided by the monthly churn rate, which is why small improvements matter so much. Going from 6% to 4% doesn't sound dramatic, but it makes the average subscriber stay about half as long again.

The most useful benchmark, though, is your own churn last quarter. Aim to beat that.

Why churn decides what a subscriber is worth

Customer lifetime value is where churn turns into money. A simple version that works for most replenishment stores:

Lifetime value = what you keep from each monthly order, after product cost, fulfilment and the subscriber discount ÷ monthly churn rate

If each order leaves you $14 after costs, a subscriber is worth about $233 at 6% churn and about $350 at 4%. That's the same customer, product and price, worth 50% more, just because they stay longer.

This is also the number to hold your acquisition spend against. If you're paying $60 in ads for each new subscriber, you have a very different business at $233 than at $350. And it's why a bigger subscribe-and-save discount is only worth it if it keeps people longer: it comes off every order in that calculation.

Look at retention by order, not just by month

A single monthly churn rate blends together customers who joined last week and customers who've been with you for two years, and those behave very differently. Two other views tell you much more about where you're losing people.

Retention by order number. Of everyone who subscribed, what share made it to their second order, their third, their sixth? Look at where the drop is steepest. A big drop before the second order points to the first impression: the wrong frequency, a surprise charge, a product that didn't live up to the page. There's more on that in making the first delivery count. A steady leak later on points to boredom, price or too much product piling up.

Retention by start month. Group subscribers by the month they joined, often called cohorts, and follow each group over time. If the subscribers who joined in March are leaving faster than the ones from January, something changed: a promotion that brought in bargain hunters, a new frequency, a supplier problem. This is also how you see whether a change you made actually worked.

Retention by order number matters most when your subscribers are on different frequencies. A subscriber on a two-month frequency only has six chances a year to decide whether to stay, so mixing them with monthly subscribers makes one monthly churn rate hard to read.

Customer churn and revenue churn

Everything so far counts subscribers. You can also count money: the share of your monthly recurring revenue (MRR) lost to cancellations, failed payments and customers reducing their order. The other side is revenue you gain from existing subscribers who add products or move to a bigger size.

Put them together and you get net revenue retention: of the recurring revenue you had from a group of subscribers a year ago, how much do they bring in now? If customers add products to their deliveries, it can be close to or even above 100%, even while some of them leave. That's the strongest sign a subscription program is healthy, and the main reason to let customers add products to their subscription themselves.

Which churn to fix first

Split your churn into voluntary and involuntary, and start with whichever is bigger relative to what's normal. In Recurly's ecommerce figures, about a third of churn is involuntary. If your share is much higher, failed payments are your quickest win.

If involuntary churn is high

These are customers who didn't decide to leave, which makes them the easiest to keep. Retry declined cards a few times over a week or two, at different times of day, and tell the customer after the first failure with a direct link to update their card. Don't wait until the retries have run out. Before each renewal, send a reminder so expired cards come to light early. There's a full playbook in how to recover failed subscription payments.

If voluntary churn is high

Find out why before you change anything. Ask in the cancel flow, then work through the answers from the most common down:

  • "I have too much." Your default frequency is too short. Change the frequencies on the product page, and let customers skip, delay or deliver less often from their account.
  • "It's too expensive." Check that the saving is easy to see on the product page and in the account, and offer a discount on the next few orders when someone leaves for this reason.
  • "I'm away." Let customers pause rather than cancel, and resume when they're back.
  • "I want something different." Let customers swap flavours, sizes or products themselves.

Every change a customer can make without contacting you is a reason to cancel that disappears. And matching the offer in the cancel flow to the reason the customer gives keeps more of the ones who do start to leave. See how to reduce subscription cancellations with a cancel flow.

A monthly churn routine

Once a month, take half an hour and look at:

  1. Churn rate, split into voluntary and involuntary, compared with last month and the same month last year.
  2. Early churn: subscribers who left before their second or third order.
  3. Cancellation reasons, and which one grew.
  4. Failed payments: how many failed, and how many were recovered.
  5. The cancel flow: how many it kept, and whether the customers it kept are still there a month later.

Pick one thing to change, change only that, and check the same numbers next month. Changing five things at once means you'll never know which one worked.

Common questions

What is a good monthly churn rate for a subscription business?

For ecommerce subscriptions, Recurly's July 2026 median is 4.25% a month. Replenishment products like supplements and household goods commonly run 5–8%, and curated boxes higher. Below 5% is good for most physical product subscriptions, but beating your own last quarter matters more than any benchmark.

How do I turn monthly churn into annual churn?

Don't multiply by 12. Subtract the monthly rate from 1, raise that to the power of 12, and subtract the result from 1. At 5% monthly churn, 0.9512 is about 0.54, so you'd lose about 46% of your subscribers over a year, not 60%.

Do paused subscriptions count as churn?

No. A paused subscriber hasn't left. Leave them out of your churn calculation and track separately how many resume.

What's the difference between churn rate and retention rate?

They're two sides of the same number. If your monthly churn rate is 6%, your monthly retention rate is 94%. Retention is usually used for groups followed over time, like "62% of January's subscribers are still subscribed".

Does Shopify show subscription churn?

Shopify's own reports are built around orders and sales, and renewals appear there as ordinary orders. Churn rate, cancellation reasons and failed payment recovery usually come from your subscription app, so check that the one you choose reports churn split into voluntary and involuntary.

The short version

  1. Churn rate is subscribers lost in a month divided by active subscribers at the start of it. Leave new subscribers out.
  2. Split it into voluntary and involuntary, and handle pauses, failed payments and prepaid plans consistently.
  3. Ecommerce subscriptions run around 4–5% a month, and replenishment products often 5–8%. Your own last quarter is the benchmark that counts.
  4. Small monthly changes are big over a year, and they decide what each subscriber is worth.
  5. Look at retention by order number and by start month to find where you lose people.
  6. Fix involuntary churn with retries and card update links, and voluntary churn by finding out why and letting customers change things themselves.
  7. Review the same five numbers every month, and change one thing at a time.
Using Vanix? Analytics shows your churn rate and MRR, with new, expansion, contraction, churned and reactivated revenue, for any period. Retention follows each start month and shows net revenue retention and estimated lifetime value, and Churn & recovery splits how subscriptions ended, from customer cancellations to failed payments, alongside your cancel flow's save rate and payment recovery rate. The monthly cancellation themes group what customers wrote when they left, so you can see which reason is growing.

Sources