Blog

Subscription emails: what to send your subscribers, and when

A subscriber hears from you far less than a one-time customer thinks about you. Most months the only contact is a charge on their card and a box on the doorstep. The few emails in between have a big say in whether they stay: a clear reminder before a renewal turns a surprise charge into a skip, and a missing one turns it into a refund request or a chargeback. This guide covers which subscription emails to send, when, what each should say, and the auto-renewal rules some of them help you meet.

Service emails, not marketing

Everything in this guide is a service email: a message about the customer's own subscription, sent because of something that happened to it. Keep these separate from your newsletter and promotions.

  • Every subscriber should get them, including customers who never agreed to marketing. A renewal reminder isn't a promotion, and nobody should miss one because they unticked a box at checkout.
  • Keep the message the point of the email. A short line about a new flavour at the bottom of a reminder is fine. A reminder that's mostly a sale banner reads as marketing, to the customer and to the rules.
  • Keep them short and plain. Customers scan these for one fact: when, how much, or what to do. Put that fact first.

The subscription emails to send

EmailWhenWhat it's for
WelcomeRight after checkoutConfirms the terms and shows where to manage the subscription.
Upcoming order reminderA few days before each renewalLets them skip, change or update their card before they're charged.
Payment failedAfter a declined renewalGets the card updated before the subscription is lost.
Cancellation confirmationWhen they cancelSays exactly when it ends and that they won't be charged again.
Pause and resumeWhen they pause or resumeSays when the next order is, or when the pause ends.
Price change noticeBefore a price goes upTells them the new price, when it starts and how to cancel.

That's six, and they cover what customers need to know. You don't need an email for every change. When customers swap a flavour or change their address in their account, confirm it on the page. An email for every small edit trains people to ignore the ones that matter.

1. The welcome email

Shopify already sends an order confirmation for the first order. The welcome email is about the subscription, which carries on after that order, and it's the one customers keep to look up how things work. Include:

  • What they'll get: the products, quantities and price of each delivery.
  • How often, and the date of the next order.
  • Where to manage it: a button that opens the subscription in their account on your store. This is the most important line in the email, and Shopify expects subscription apps to tell buyers where to manage what they bought.
  • That they can skip, change or cancel anytime, and how. The promise that got them to subscribe belongs in writing.

Auto-renewal laws ask for much the same thing. California's, for example, expects an acknowledgment after sign-up that sets out the terms, the cancellation policy and how to cancel, in a form the customer can keep. A good welcome email does that without reading like a contract.

2. The upcoming order reminder

If you send only one email beyond the welcome, make it this one. A renewal reminder (or "upcoming order" email) goes out a few days before each charge, and it does three jobs at once:

  • It prevents overstock. A customer who still has half a bag can skip or move the order instead of cancelling because product is piling up.
  • It prevents surprise charges. A charge the customer expected is far less likely to become a refund request or a chargeback, and chargebacks cost you a fee on top of the order.
  • It catches card problems early. A customer who sees the reminder can update an expired card before the renewal fails, not after.

When to send it

Three to seven days before the charge suits most stores. It needs to be long enough for the customer to act, and short enough that they still remember it when the charge appears. If you lock orders a few days ahead to start packing, send the reminder before that point, so the "change it" link still does something.

What to put in it

  • The date, first, in the subject line: "Your next order is on March 14".
  • What's in the order, the total, and where it's going.
  • One clear link to skip, swap or change it, with the deadline for changes.
  • How often it renews, and that they can cancel from the same page.
Won't a reminder make people cancel? A few, yes: some subscribers who'd forgotten will leave. But they'd have left anyway, after a charge they didn't expect, and some of them through their bank. Customers who stay because they forgot aren't loyal, they're a chargeback waiting to happen. The ones a reminder keeps, by letting them skip instead of cancel, are worth far more.

3. Payment failed

When a renewal is declined, tell the customer straight away, with a direct link to update their card. Don't wait for every retry to fail first. Many declines are expired or replaced cards, and the customer can fix that in a minute if they know.

Keep it calm and factual: the payment didn't go through, here's the link, and here's when you'll try again. Avoid "your account is suspended" language for what's usually a new card number. Send a last reminder before the final retry, and a final email if the subscription is paused or cancelled because of it. There's a full playbook in how to recover failed subscription payments.

4. Cancellation confirmation

Always confirm a cancellation by email, with the date it takes effect and a plain "you won't be charged again". It's the email that stops a customer checking their bank statement nervously for the next two months, and many places expect one.

  • If the subscription runs to the end of a paid cycle, say the end date and give them a way to keep it until then.
  • Don't put another save offer in it. They've already said no to one in the cancel flow, and a second here makes the confirmation feel like a trap.
  • Don't add them to a win-back campaign unless they've agreed to marketing. Leaving your subscription isn't consent to promotions.

5. Pause and resume

A pause confirmation should say when the subscription resumes, if it does on its own, and how to resume it early. If the pause has an end date, a reminder a few days before the first order after it is worth more than the confirmation: by then, the customer may have forgotten they ever paused.

6. Price change notice

Sooner or later your costs go up. Before a subscriber pays a higher price, tell them in a separate email, not a line in a reminder. Include the old price, the new price, the date it starts, and how to cancel or change their subscription before then.

California's amended auto-renewal law, in force since July 2025, requires this notice no less than 7 and no more than 30 days before the new price applies, along with how to cancel. Two to three weeks ahead fits that window and gives customers time to decide. It also reads as fair, and fair is what keeps people through a price rise.

Emails and auto-renewal laws

Several US states have automatic renewal laws, and California's is the strictest that most stores will meet. Since July 2025, for subscriptions started or changed from then on, it includes:

  • A reminder at least once a year, in the same medium the customer signed up in (for an online store, email), covering the product, how often and how much they're charged, and how to cancel.
  • Notice of a price change 7 to 30 days ahead, with how to cancel.
  • Records of the customer's consent, kept for at least three years, or one year after the subscription ends, whichever is longer.

The simplest way to meet the yearly reminder is to make every upcoming order reminder include those things: what's in the order, how much, how often, and how to cancel. Then it goes out with every order, not once a year from a calendar you have to remember.

At the federal level, the FTC's 2024 "click to cancel" rule was struck down by a court in July 2025, and the FTC reopened rulemaking in 2026. The existing federal law on online subscriptions (ROSCA) still applies, and still requires clear terms and an easy way to cancel. This guide isn't legal advice. If you sell a lot in California or another state with an auto-renewal law, have a lawyer look over your emails and checkout once.

Make sure they arrive

A reminder in the spam folder does nothing. A few things help service emails land in the inbox:

  • Send from your own domain, like orders@yourstore.com, signed with DKIM. Gmail requires every sender to authenticate with SPF or DKIM, and stores sending more than 5,000 emails a day to Gmail need both, plus a DMARC record. A DMARC record with a policy of p=none is enough to start, and it never blocks mail.
  • Make the store name the sender name, and let replies reach a real inbox. Customers reply to these emails with real questions.
  • Stop emailing addresses that bounce or mark you as spam. Gmail wants complaints kept under 0.3% of what you send, and a list of dead addresses drags your whole store's mail down with it.
  • Send a test of each one to yourself and read it on a phone, with a real subscription's details filled in.

Common questions

Does Shopify send subscription emails?

Shopify sends its usual order and shipping notifications, and renewals are ordinary Shopify orders. The subscription emails themselves, like the welcome email, renewal reminders and cancellation confirmations, come from your subscription app. Check under Settings → Notifications in Shopify what goes out for renewal orders, so customers don't get two receipts for the same thing.

How many days before renewal should I send a reminder?

Three to seven days suits most replenishment stores. Send it early enough for the customer to act before you lock the order, and for a price change, 7 to 30 days ahead to meet California's rules.

Can customers unsubscribe from subscription emails?

Service emails about their own subscription don't need a marketing unsubscribe, and customers shouldn't be able to miss a renewal notice by accident. If someone really doesn't want reminders, the respectful answer is to make cancelling or pausing easy, not to keep charging them in silence.

Should I send subscription reminders by SMS?

SMS is good for urgent messages, like a failed payment, if the customer has agreed to texts. Use it alongside email, not instead of it. Texting customers needs their consent under rules that are stricter than email's, and email is where they'll look for the details later.

The short version

  1. Treat subscription emails as service messages, separate from marketing, and send them to every subscriber.
  2. Welcome: what, how often, the next date, and a button to manage it.
  3. Reminder: 3–7 days before each order, with the date first and one link to change it.
  4. Payment failed: straight away, with a link to update the card.
  5. Cancellation: the end date and "you won't be charged again", with no second offer.
  6. Price change: its own email, 7–30 days ahead, with how to cancel.
  7. Put the product, price, frequency and how to cancel in every reminder, and you've covered California's yearly reminder too.
  8. Send from your own domain with DKIM and DMARC, and stop emailing addresses that bounce.
Using Vanix? Customer Emails sends the welcome email, upcoming order reminders 1 to 14 days ahead, and confirmations when a subscription is cancelled, scheduled to end, kept, paused or resumed, each in your store's name and editable. Once you switch reminders on, each one says what's in the order, the total, how often it renews and that the customer can cancel from their account, the things California's yearly reminder needs. Billing recovery sends the failed payment emails with each retry, you can send from your own domain, and addresses that bounce or complain are stopped automatically.

Sources