Blog

How to increase subscription order value without bigger discounts

Most advice on growing a subscription business is about getting more subscribers or keeping them longer. There's a third lever that gets less attention: getting a little more into each box. A subscriber who adds a $12 item to the next delivery costs you almost nothing extra to ship, and they're already a customer who trusts you. This guide covers how to increase subscription order value in ways customers welcome, without leaning on bigger discounts.

Why order value matters more for subscriptions

Every subscription order carries costs that don't change with what's inside it: picking and packing, the box, and usually most of the shipping. A bigger order spreads those costs over more product, so each extra dollar of order value earns you more than the dollar before it.

Say a renewal is $34 and leaves you $14 after product cost, packing and shipping. The customer adds a $12 item that costs you $5. The box was going out anyway, so nearly all of the remaining $7 is yours. That order now leaves you $21 instead of $14, half as much again, from one small add.

And because a subscriber's lifetime value is what each order leaves you divided by your churn rate, that same increase raises what every subscriber who adds is worth, without spending anything on finding new ones. There's more on that calculation in subscription churn rate.

1. Let subscribers add to their next order

The single most useful thing you can offer is a way to add a product to the next delivery only. It's the lowest-commitment way for a subscriber to buy more: they're not signing up for anything new, just putting something in a box that's already coming. Think of a mug with the coffee, a treat with the dog food, a travel size before a holiday.

  • Charge the normal price. A one-time add doesn't need a discount to be attractive. The appeal is that it arrives with the order they're already getting, often with no shipping cost of its own.
  • Remove it after that order. The customer should never find a one-time item still on their subscription a month later. Make it clear before they confirm that it's for the next delivery only.
  • Let them change their mind. Until you start packing, a customer should be able to take it off again.

2. Let them add to every delivery

Some products belong on the subscription itself: a second flavour they've come to like, filters that wear out at the same rate as the coffee, a shampoo to go with the conditioner. Adding a product to every delivery is a bigger decision for the customer, so give it the same terms as the rest of the subscription, with the subscriber discount on the new item too.

Only offer recurring adds on products that run out at roughly the same pace as the rest of the order. A product that lasts three times as long piles up, and an overflowing cupboard is one of the most common reasons subscribers cancel. If it doesn't fit the rhythm, offer it for the next delivery only.

3. Choose what to offer

A short, relevant list beats your whole catalogue. Customers scrolling fifty products on their account page usually add nothing. Good candidates:

  • Things that go with what they already get: accessories, refills, the matching product in a set.
  • Small, low-risk items under the price of the main product. A $10 add is an easy yes; a $60 one is a separate purchase decision.
  • Seasonal and limited products, which give regular subscribers a reason to look at the page.
  • Trial sizes of other products, so a subscriber can try something before swapping to it or adding it for good.

Keep out-of-stock products off the list. A product added three weeks before the order that's sold out on the day can hold up the whole renewal, and a subscriber whose order failed because of something you offered them won't add anything again.

4. Make it easy to size up

A subscriber who gets through a 250 g bag every two weeks might be better served by a 1 kg bag every month. They pay less per gram and get fewer deliveries to deal with, and you get a bigger order with the same packing and shipping. Let customers swap to a different size of what they already get from their account, and show both prices so the saving is obvious.

Pair a size change with a frequency change where it makes sense, or the customer ends up with twice as much product on the same schedule. And don't block moving to a smaller size. A subscriber who can't size down when money is tight will often cancel instead, and a smaller order is worth more than no order.

5. Ask at the right moment: the renewal reminder

The best time to suggest an add is when the subscriber is already thinking about their next order, and that's when your upcoming order reminder lands. A line such as "Want anything else in this box? Add it before Friday" next to the manage link turns a service email into the one place where adding is natural.

Keep it to one line. The reminder's job is to tell the customer what's coming and when, and a reminder that reads like a catalogue loses both jobs. There's more on what belongs in it in subscription emails: what to send, and when.

6. Use shipping, carefully

If you charge for shipping on subscription orders, a free shipping threshold is one of the strongest reasons to add something: "Add $8 more for free delivery" is easy to understand. If you already ship subscriptions free, it's one less reason, but it also means every add rides in a box you've already paid for.

Either way, make sure the shipping rate follows the order. If a subscriber adds enough to cross into a heavier rate, or enough to qualify for free shipping, the rate on the next order should change with it. Otherwise you either eat the difference on every add or charge customers for shipping they've earned their way out of.

What not to do

  • Never add products without asking. In the US, merchandise sent without being ordered can be kept by the customer as a gift, and billing for it is unlawful. "We've added a sample to your next box for $6, remove it if you don't want it" is that, and it's the fastest way to turn a loyal subscriber into a chargeback.
  • Don't upsell in the cancel flow, unless the customer said they wanted something different. Someone leaving because they have too much doesn't want more. See how to reduce subscription cancellations.
  • Don't upsell in the failed payment email. The only thing that email should ask for is a new card.
  • Don't win order value with discounts. A bigger discount for a bigger order gives back much of what the bigger order earned. The point of add-ons is that they ride on costs you've already paid.

How to measure it

Watch three numbers, monthly:

  1. Average renewal order value, kept separate from first orders and one-time purchases.
  2. The share of renewals with something added, so you can tell whether a rise came from more people adding or a few adding a lot.
  3. Expansion revenue: recurring revenue gained from existing subscribers adding to every delivery or sizing up. Set against what you lose to cancellations and downsizing, it gives you net revenue retention.

Then check that subscribers who add things don't cancel faster. They should stay at least as long, since a subscription they've shaped to fit them is harder to give up. If they cancel faster, you're probably offering things that pile up.

Common questions

What is a good average order value for a subscription?

It depends entirely on your products, so there isn't a useful benchmark. Compare your renewal order value with your own first orders and with last quarter, and look at how much of each order is left after fixed costs like packing and shipping.

Should one-time add-ons get the subscriber discount?

They don't need to. A one-time add is convenient because it arrives in a box that's already coming, and that's usually reason enough. Keep the subscriber discount for things added to every delivery, where the customer is committing to more.

Is upselling subscribers bad for retention?

Not when it's an option they choose. Pushy or automatic upsells hurt, because they make the subscription feel like something done to the customer. A clear way to add something, offered at the right moment and easy to undo, tends to make the subscription fit them better.

The short version

  1. Extra order value is mostly profit, because packing and shipping are already paid for.
  2. Let subscribers add to their next order at the normal price, and take it off after.
  3. Offer adds to every delivery only for products that run out at the same pace.
  4. Keep the list short, relevant, cheap relative to the main product, and in stock.
  5. Make it easy to move to a bigger size, and don't block moving to a smaller one.
  6. Suggest an add in the renewal reminder, in one line.
  7. Make sure the shipping rate follows the order.
  8. Never add anything without asking, and never upsell to someone who's leaving or whose card failed.
Using Vanix? The Add to subscription rule lets customers add products on every delivery, with the plan's discount, or on the next delivery only, at full price and removed after that order. You choose which products, how many adds per cycle, and a cut-off before billing, and out-of-stock products can be left out. Swap rules let customers change size or product with price limits, the delivery rate is re-quoted when an order changes, and you can edit the upcoming order reminder to suggest an add. Analytics shows average order value and expansion revenue.

Sources