Blog

How to choose subscription delivery frequencies that customers keep

How often a subscription delivers sounds like a small setting. It isn't. Set it too often and product piles up in the cupboard until the customer cancels to make it stop. Set it too rarely and they run out, buy somewhere else in the gap, and start to wonder what the subscription is for. Getting the delivery frequency right prevents cancellations before any cancel flow has to save them. This guide covers how to work out the right frequencies for your products, which to make the default, and how to tell when they're wrong.

Why frequency matters so much

"I have too much" is one of the most common reasons subscribers give for cancelling a replenishment product, and it's nearly always a frequency problem. A delivery schedule that's a little faster than the customer's use doesn't feel wrong at first. It builds slowly: a spare bag this month, two next month, until a cupboard full of your product makes the subscription feel like a burden.

Too slow has its own cost, and it's quieter. A customer who runs out a week early buys from the supermarket or a competitor to fill the gap. Do that a few times and the subscription stops being how they buy from you.

The goal is a schedule that delivers a little before they run out, close enough to their real use that nothing builds up.

Start from how long the product lasts

Work out how long one unit lasts a typical customer. For some products that's on the label: 60 capsules at 2 a day is 30 days. For others it's a usage estimate: a 1 kg bag of coffee at about 30 g a day lasts a little over a month.

That's a starting point, but label maths assumes people use the product the way the label says. Many don't. Your order history is a better guide.

Check it against your order history

Customers who already reorder a product without a subscription are telling you how long it lasts them. To find out:

  1. Export your orders. In Shopify admin, go to Orders, choose Export, and export a year or so of orders. The file has a row per item with the customer's email, the order date, the product and the quantity.
  2. Keep one product. In a spreadsheet, filter to the product you're setting up, and sort by email, then date.
  3. Work out the gap between orders. For each customer who ordered it more than once, count the days between one order and the next. If they bought two at once, halve the gap for one unit.
  4. Take the median, not the average. A customer who forgot about you for six months would drag the average up. The median, the middle value, is closer to how long the product lasts for a typical regular customer.

You don't need hundreds of customers for this. Twenty or thirty repeat buyers of a product usually show a clear middle. If their gap is noticeably longer than the label suggests, believe the customers.

Offer two or three frequencies around it

One frequency doesn't fit everyone, because households use different amounts. A handful of choices does:

  • The middle one at your median gap, rounded to a frequency that's easy to say.
  • One shorter, for heavier users and larger households.
  • One longer, for lighter users. Make this one generous, about half as long again, because it's the one that stops "too much" cancellations.

For the coffee above, with a median gap of about five weeks, that might be every 3, 5 and 7 weeks, or every 4, 6 and 8. Resist offering every option from weekly to quarterly. A long list makes the choice on the product page harder, and most of the options will be wrong for that product anyway.

Pick the default carefully

Most customers take whichever frequency is selected when they arrive, so the default does most of the work. Make it the middle frequency, and if you're unsure between two, choose the longer one.

The reason is that the two mistakes aren't equal. A customer who runs out early can fix it in a minute by moving their next order earlier. A customer with too much has to notice, find the right setting and change it, and many cancel instead. A slightly long default, with an easy way to get the next order sooner, fails more gently.

Weeks or months?

This matters more than it looks. "Every 4 weeks" and "every month" sound the same, but every 4 weeks is 13 deliveries a year and every month is 12.

That extra delivery adds up. A 30-day bottle on a 4-week schedule arrives two days early every time, and over a year the customer ends up with nearly a whole spare bottle. That's exactly the slow build-up that ends in "I have too much".

  • Use months for products sold as a month's supply: supplements, vitamins, contact lenses, anything with "30 days" on the box. It also matches how customers think about their budget.
  • Use weeks for products used at a steady rate that doesn't line up with months: pet food, coffee, nappies. It lets you fit the schedule to real use, like every 5 weeks, which months can't.

Keep frequencies consistent across similar products

If customers can swap between products, like one coffee for another or chicken for salmon, give those products the same frequencies. Otherwise a customer on "every 5 weeks" who swaps to a product sold only monthly has nowhere to land, and the swap either fails or quietly changes their schedule.

The same goes for products often bought together. If the coffee comes every 5 weeks and the filters only every 2 months, the customer can't keep both on one subscription.

Keep the discount the same across frequencies

It can be tempting to reward more frequent deliveries with a bigger discount. Don't. It nudges customers towards a schedule faster than their real use, which is the fastest way to a cupboard full of product and a cancellation. A single discount at every frequency lets customers choose on how fast they use the product, which is the choice you want them to make. There's more on setting the discount in how much your subscribe-and-save discount should be.

Let customers change it

However carefully you choose, some customers will be on the wrong frequency, and their needs change: a new puppy, a second coffee drinker, a summer away. Let them fix it from their account:

  • Change frequency, from the frequencies you offer, for a lasting fix.
  • Skip or move the next order, for a one-off.
  • Order now, for when they've run out early.

All three are worth offering. A customer who can only skip will skip every third order forever, and one who can't do anything will cancel. There's more on these in the subscription customer portal guide.

Signs your frequencies are wrong

  • "I have too much" among cancellation reasons for one product: the default is too short.
  • Lots of skips on one frequency: it's faster than customers' use.
  • Customers moving orders earlier or ordering early: it's slower than their use.
  • Many customers changing to the same frequency after their first order: that's the one to make the default.
  • One frequency keeping subscribers much longer than another for the same product: look at why, and consider making it the default.

Check these once a quarter. When you change a default, existing subscribers keep their schedule, so the effect shows in new subscribers first.

Common questions

What's the most common subscription frequency?

Monthly is the most familiar, but the best frequency depends entirely on how long your product lasts. A month's supply should come monthly; a bag that lasts five weeks should come every five weeks.

Should I offer weekly subscriptions?

Only for products customers get through in about a week, like fresh food or large households' pet food. For most replenishment products, weekly is far faster than anyone uses them, and it fills cupboards.

How many frequency options should I offer?

Two or three for most products, centred on how long the product lasts. More choices make the product page harder to use without helping many customers.

Do existing subscribers change when I change my frequencies?

With most Shopify subscription apps, no. Changing a plan affects new subscribers; existing ones keep the frequency they chose until they change it themselves.

The short version

  1. Too-frequent deliveries are behind many "I have too much" cancellations.
  2. Start from how long the product lasts, then check it against the median gap between your customers' reorders.
  3. Offer two or three frequencies around that gap, with a generous longer one.
  4. Make the middle one the default, and when unsure, choose the longer.
  5. Use months for a month's supply and weeks for steady use, and remember every 4 weeks is 13 deliveries a year.
  6. Give swappable products the same frequencies, and keep the discount the same at every frequency.
  7. Let customers change frequency, skip and order early, and watch the signals each quarter.
Using Vanix? Plans offer up to 20 frequencies in days, weeks, months or years, each with its own discount. The delivery frequency rule lets customers move to any frequency your plans offer for everything on their subscription, and reschedule and skip and Ship now cover the one-offs. In Analytics, Products & plans shows how often your subscriptions bill and which frequencies keep their subscribers longest.

Sources

  • Shopify Help Center, Exporting orders, on exporting orders and the columns the file includes.